Is a Variable Speed Pool Pump Worth It?

The pump is the hardest working piece of equipment on your pool. It runs for hours every day, all year, so it's also the part that shows up most on the power bill. When an old pump dies, or the bills start to sting over a Brisbane summer, the question we get asked at the counter is whether a variable speed pump is worth the extra money. For a lot of pools the answer is yes. It isn't for every pool though, and it only pays off if the pump is set up properly.
Single speed and variable speed: the difference
A single speed pump does one thing. Switch it on and it runs flat out until the timer turns it off. That's simple and reliable, but a pool only needs full flow for a few jobs, like vacuuming, backwashing or running some cleaners. The rest of the time it's just filtering, and full speed is more than that needs.
A variable speed pump lets you choose how fast the motor spins. Most have low, medium and high settings that can be adjusted, and many have a built-in timer. You run it low for everyday filtering and step it up only when a job needs the extra flow.
Why slower costs less to run
The saving comes from the way pumps use power. Slow a pump down and the flow drops, but the power it draws drops a lot faster. At half speed a pump moves roughly half the water for far less than half the power. Because it's moving less water, you run it for more hours to turn the pool over, and it still uses less power overall.
Running slower helps in other ways too:
- Less noise. A pump on low speed is much quieter, which matters when the equipment sits under a bedroom window or beside the neighbour's fence.
- Better filtering. Water moving slowly through the filter gives it more chance to trap fine dirt.
- Steadier chlorine. A salt chlorinator only makes chlorine while the pump is running, so longer hours spread it through the day.
New pool pumps sold in Australia carry an energy rating label with a star rating, the same idea as a fridge or washing machine. It's the easiest way to compare what two pumps will cost to run.
What the low speed still has to do
The lowest setting isn't automatically the right one. The speed you choose still has to keep everything else working:
- Salt chlorinator. The cell needs a minimum flow. Too slow and many chlorinators show a low-flow warning and stop making chlorine. A scaled-up cell makes it worse, so see how to check and clean your cell.
- Skimming. The skimmer has to pull enough water to draw leaves off the surface.
- Pool cleaner. A suction cleaner needs a certain flow to move. Many pools run a higher speed for the hours the cleaner works, then drop back. See choosing a pool cleaner.
- Heating. Solar heating and heat pumps need a minimum flow too. If yours runs off the filter pump, the speed has to suit it.
- Backwashing and vacuuming. Use high speed for both, then turn it back down.
A variable speed pump left on high all day saves nothing. The saving is made in the setup, and it usually takes some adjusting over the first few weeks to find the lowest speed that keeps the water clear.
When a single speed pump still makes sense
A variable speed pump isn't always the right call:
- The pump does a job that needs full flow anyway, like a water feature, spa jets or an in-floor cleaning system.
- It's a small pool with short running hours, where the saving is smaller and takes longer to cover the higher purchase price.
- The budget is tight right now. A single speed pump costs less up front and will still do the job.
Repair or replace?
Not every sick pump needs replacing. A pump that runs but doesn't move water often has an air leak or a blockage, not a dead motor. Our guide to a pool pump that won't prime covers the usual causes. A leaking seal, a failed capacitor or a worn lid O-ring are all repairs worth doing on a pump that's otherwise sound.
Signs it's closer to the end are a loud grinding or screaming noise from the motor, water dripping from between the motor and the pump body, tripping the safety switch, or cutting out when it gets hot. On an older pump with more than one of those, the money is usually better spent on a new one.
Before you buy
- Size it to the pool, not bigger. A pump has to match the filter and the pipework. One that's too strong for the filter wastes power and can damage it. The filter's maximum flow rate is on its label.
- Check the fit. A pump with the same pipe connections and height as the old one is a simpler swap. Otherwise allow for some re-plumbing.
- Compare more than the price. Check the star rating, the warranty and whether parts are easy to get.
- Think about when it runs. If you have solar panels, running the pump through the middle of the day uses your own power. On an economy tariff, power is only available for part of the day, so the timer has to suit.
- Leave the wiring to an electrician. Most pumps plug into a weatherproof power point. Anything more than that is a job for a licensed electrician.
Not sure which pump suits your pool? Bring the make and model of your current pump and filter into our shop at 304-306 Junction Rd, Clayfield and we'll talk you through it, or call (07) 3857 8530. Our technicians repair and replace pool pumps and will tell you honestly which way to go. You can also book a service and have the pump, filter and cleaner checked while we're there.